金币
UID11388
帖子
主题
积分1356
注册时间2011-12-28
最后登录1970-1-1
听众
性别保密
|
发表于 2016-11-9 09:35:44
|
显示全部楼层
引用:此商品在美国亚马逊上最有用的商品评论 (beta)
美国亚马逊: 平均1.0 星 1 条评论
1/1 人认为此评论有用
平均1.0 星 Poor content, title not significant 2013年12月20日
评论者 Quality Engineer, Six Sigma black belt - 已在美国亚马逊上发表
版本: 精装 已确认购买
I was expecting to find a new 'AIAG' manual but for the FDA.
I was disappointed.
Very disappointing book, for many reasons:
- Only a small part is dedicated to SPC, one chapter. Why to give so much space to many other statistical techniques (DOE, MSA, Hypot Test) while the person who buy this book is expecting to have a compendium of SPC applied to Medtech?
- The cases from the FDA are fake. The only relationship to the FDA industry is that the author changed the title to something which could sound like FDA related
- Very superficial in general. No theory.
- Does not give "best practise" suggestion. If this is true that the authors have 20 year of experience using this technique, why do not put more detailed case-studies?
In conclusion: Stay far from this book, you can find the same info in any other statistical book about SPC of Six Sigma.
The title is just for marketing, saying nothing. |
|